Gita–Khestra Khestragya Vibhag Yog–The individual and the Ultimate Consciousness–Chap 13
3February 17, 2013 by styagi68
Verse 1: Arjun asks about the matter/energy (base material-prakriti) and causation(purush), object (kshetra) and subject (kshetragya). knowledge and knower. These questions are really getting to the heart of the philosophy now.
Verse 2: Krishna says that this body is the base material and the consciousness is the causation. Those who know this are the ones knowledgeable about subject and object.
Verse 3: Knowing that I am the awareness in every body is the real knowledge. This is differentiating between our memory, our physical body which is different for each living entity from the soul (the causation) inside which is common between all living entity. So while we have accumulated different responses and memories our inherent nature/causation is the same.
Verse 4-7: Krishna says that physical matter, energy and space (earth, water, air, fire and ether), sense of separate ego, intellect and the unmanifest element in the material nature, the ten sense and the mind and the five sense objects desires, disdain, happiness distress, all this the object or the field of activity which is constantly modified by six transformations from birth to death.
Verse 8-12: 1) Humility, 2) sincerity, 3) non-violence, 4) tolerance, 5) simplicity, 6) service to teacher, 7) hygiene, 8) steadfastness, 9) self-control, 10) sacrifice of sense pleasures, 11) lack of self ego, 12) awareness of distress or elation caused by birth, death, old age and disease, 13) equipoise, 14) lack of excessive attachment to family and home, 15) consistent, 16) even minded to auspicious and inauspicious (isht-anisht), 17) preference for solitude, 18) away from mundane society, 19) devotional selfless service through yog of uniting selfish interests with universal interests, 20) constant meditation on the Ultimate Truth to achieve self-realization all these are the real knowledge and everything contrary to this a false knowledge. This is a list of 20 supreme qualities to cultivate. If our education and upbringing focused on these attributes, we would create a harmonious, prosperous existence.
Verse 13-14: Krishna says he will describe the eternal truth which is everywhere and basis of everything.
Verse 15-17: The Ultimate Truth is aware of all senses, yet it is not impacted by them, it is unattached and yet is the basis of everything; beyond material nature yet the basis of the material nature. It is inside all living entities and outside, it is stationary and mobile. It is subatomic (sukshamtvat) and therefore far from comprehensible but all around us. It is indivisible but appears divided in various living forms and manifests as creator, preserver and destroyer of everything.
Verse 18-19: The Ultimate Truth is in the heart of all but only realizable on wisdom gained through directly experiencing it. This is a description used by many a different life experiences. Like becoming a parent, the way it feels can never be fully explained to someone who has not experienced it yet. The full understanding of it comes through direct experience.
Verse 20: Know that both the material nature (matter and energy) and consciousness or primal cause (purush) are both without beginning. All modifications and changes are only in the material nature as the consciousness is without change.
Verse 21: Material energy (prakriti) is responsible cause and effect in matter of creation. Soul (purush) is responsible for experiencing happiness and distress. This is a complex verse. It states that all cause and effect is in the world of nature. All experiential world is in the domain of soul (or the primal cause). How does this square up with the soul (purush) being the sole and first cause?
Verse 22: The soul situated in material body experiences the three modes of material energy (sat, rajas, tamas). Attachment to these three modes causes innumerable births in various forms.
Verse 23-24: Within the body, beyond the individual consciousness (purush) is the Ultimate Consciousness which is the observer (updarshata), sanctioner (anumanta), preserver, experiencer (bhokta) and ultimate controller (maha ishvarah). Understanding this in terms of Ultimate and individual consciousness, the three modes of material nature is the key to salvation. So the ultimate consciousness is separately defined here as something different from the material energy and the individual consciousness.
Verse 25-26: Some realize Ultimate Consciousness through meditating on the consciousness, others through study of matter and spirit (sankhya) and some others through the science of performing action in service of universal good. Some who don’t understand these methods, engage in worship simply by hearing from other learned people and also are liberated.
Verse 27: All living entities come into being by the interaction of subject and object (kshetra and kshetragya).
Verse 28-29: Anyone who perceives the ultimate consciousness residing in all equally perceives the truth. One who is able to see equality in others without degrading self has seen the truth.
Verse 30: Anyone who perceives that the activities are all being done in the material energy world such a person realizes that the Ultimate Consciousness is the non-doer. It appears that we are moving in the zone of the individual consciousness not having any free will.
Verse 31: One who sees the unity of material nature in the diversity of the life forms, then the Ultimate Truth is attained.
Verse 32: the Ultimate Consciousness is without beginning, without change, without any material qualities and though residing in the body it is never impacted nor it does anything.
Verse 33: The space is everywhere but is not entangled with anything due to its subtlety similarly the Ultimate Consciousness is everywhere but does not get entangled with any living form.
Verse 34-35: Just like sun energies the whole world, similarly the Ultimate Consciousness and the individual consciousness energize the objective world.
This chapter requires re-reading, thinking and meditation. The concept of non-doer, yet controller is confusing. As is the concept of soul that experiences everything but does not get entangled in it. Also the concept of all cause and effect in material nature but the Ultimate Consciousness being the primal cause. It appears that there are some statements which overlap or may even contradict.
This chapter is an extension of Chapter 9 and delves further into the relationship between the body (also called Kshetra, field) and the knower of the body (called Kshetra-jna, field-knower)
The body is called the field simply because it is the play-field in which various activities occur such as birth, varoius moods, thoughts, aging, disease and death. This represents the lower nature of being, the Prakriti
But as the foundation of this body-mind-intellect, there exists a knower, an intelligent sub-stratum if you will. This sub-stratum that is not the doer, that is not the thinker and that is not the emotion but a silent witness to the actions, emotions and thoughts – it is that which is called the Field-Knower (Kshetra-jna). Notice the suffix “jna” attached which is the same jna as in Jnanam, Jneyam, Brahma-jna….etc denoting knowing
So who or what is this field-knower, Kshetra-jna?
This all knowing Force is none other than Para-Brahman (God) also called Purusha, who despite seemingly divisible in all creations is in reality indivisible and without boundaries (verse16, avibhaktam ca bhuteshu, vibhaktam eva ca sthitam). This argument is one of the fundamental arguments of the Upanishads called avicched-avichhed-vada (boundaries and boundary less argument) and Krishna presents this here in a simpler form to help Arjuna along
The next verse 17 is the most critical in this chapter and presents the nature of Para-Brahman (field knower, God) in even more clearer light by pointing out that It is the Light of all Lights, said to be beyond darkness ( jyothisam api Jyothis, Tamasaf Param Ucchayate). He is the knowledge (Jnanam), the object of knowledge (Jneyam) and the place you reach with the knowledge (Jnana-gamyam), all rolled in one!
Hence, this chapter completes the explanation of Para Brahman (God) and its true nature that started in Chapter 9
Note this is an Advaita Vedantic (non dualistic vedantic) interpretation of this chapter. Equally valid dvita and vishst Advaita (dualistic and modified non dualistic) interpretations exist and use the term Kshetra-jna to refer to the individual soul controlled by the supreme soul rather than referring to the supreme soul itself
Some of Sandeep’s queries
Non-doer yet controller, Soul as the experiencer but not getting entangled ……etc
The simplest analogy is to think of an actor and the character that he plays. Say the famous character of the Psycho Norman Bates played by Anthony Perkins. We are scared by the actions of the psychotic Bates and relieved when finally Bates is neutralized. Clearly, Bates (or the illusion that we call Bates) is the doer and his actions cause fear in us and scare the hell out of us
But what about the actor himself, Perkins and his relationship with Bates. Perkins is NOT the doer as he is not the one causing fear, Bates the psycho is. But is Perkins not the controller of the character (the illusion) that we call Bates who scares us?
Such is the distinction between the body-mind-intellect (Bates the Psycho) entangled in this illusionary material world (the movie) and the Soul (Anthony Perkins) who controls the character but is NOT the doer!
Also, is the Soul (Anthony Perkins) entangled and trapped in the illusion that is the Psycho Bates? Of course not, we know that Perkins moved on and performed several other characters. Similarly the Soul does not get entangled and moves on till it reaches the resting place -the Supreme Being and then retires once and for all from playing further characters
Sri
Let us take your example of an actor playing out a role. In this case the character has no free will as it was being played out according to the script by the actor. But the actor clearly had free will in terms of playing out the character in the way he wanted. Maybe he made decisions about how to walk, how to tilt his head and how to deliver a particular dialogue. So if our soul is the actor, is it following the script with some free will? Is it completely following the script with no free will?
Also if the soul is unentangled then where is the question of the soul to bear the fruits of actions and be born in higher or lower form?